This Higher-tier question involves combining overlapping data.
Check that each person is counted only once.
At Higher tier, probability questions involving preferences often require a clear understanding of how overlapping sets work. When two options are given, such as flavours or choices, it is common for some individuals to prefer both. This overlap must be handled carefully to avoid errors.
The key idea is that adding the sizes of two groups usually leads to double counting. Anyone who belongs to both groups is included twice, once in each total. To correct this, the shared group must be subtracted once. This adjustment ensures that each individual is counted exactly once.
This reasoning is formalised in the inclusion–exclusion principle. Although the numbers may change from question to question, the structure of the method remains the same. Understanding the structure allows you to tackle unfamiliar problems with confidence.
A Venn diagram can be particularly helpful at Higher tier. By drawing two overlapping circles, you can see three distinct regions: those who prefer only the first option, those who prefer only the second option, and those who prefer both. The total number who prefer at least one option is found by adding all three regions together.
Consider a similar situation involving product choices in a shop. Some customers buy one product, some buy another, and some buy both. If a manager wants to know the probability that a randomly chosen customer buys at least one of the products, the overlap must be included only once. This shows how the same mathematical idea applies beyond school-based examples.
After finding the correct number of favourable outcomes, the probability is calculated by dividing by the total number of possible outcomes. In survey problems, this total is usually the total number of people surveyed. At Higher tier, answers are typically left as fractions unless the question specifies otherwise.
Common mistakes include subtracting the overlap twice, forgetting to include it at all, or dividing by the wrong total. Writing out the structure of the calculation before substituting values can help avoid these errors.
These types of questions are a key part of GCSE Higher probability because they link algebraic thinking with data interpretation. Mastering them prepares students for more advanced topics such as conditional probability and statistical analysis.
A strong exam technique is to label each part of a diagram or calculation clearly. This makes your working easier to follow and reduces the chance of losing marks through careless mistakes.
Enjoyed this question?